How to Check Your Paycheck for Overtime Errors (Ontario 44h and US 40h Worked Examples)

Payroll mistakes happen: a missed punch, a shift that crossed midnight split wrong, overtime calculated on the wrong threshold. The only way to catch them is to keep your own record and do the math. Here's how, with two worked examples.

This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Overtime rules vary by province, state, industry and contract; check your local employment standards.

Step 1: Record every shift yourself

Start time, end time, unpaid break. Write it down when the shift ends, not on payday. A shift from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. is one 8-hour shift, even though it crosses midnight.

Step 2: Know your overtime threshold

  • Ontario: overtime generally starts after 44 hours in a work week, at 1.5× your regular rate.
  • U.S. federal (FLSA): overtime generally starts after 40 hours in a work week for non-exempt employees, at 1.5× the regular rate. Some states add daily overtime rules.

Worked example 1: Ontario, $20/hour

Week: five 9.5-hour shifts with a 30-minute unpaid break each = 9 paid hours × 5 = 45 hours.

  • Regular: 44 h × $20 = $880.00
  • Overtime: 1 h × $30 = $30.00
  • Expected gross: $910.00

Worked example 2: U.S. federal, $18/hour

Same 45 hours.

  • Regular: 40 h × $18 = $720.00
  • Overtime: 5 h × $27 = $135.00
  • Expected gross: $855.00

Step 3: Compare with your pay stub

Match hours first, then rates, then totals. If hours differ, find the shift. If hours match but the total doesn't, check whether overtime was applied and at what rate. Bring your dated record when you ask payroll; specifics get fixed faster than "I think it's short."

Want your shifts tracked and checked on your phone?

EarnCheck: Shift & Pay Tracker is an iPhone app for keeping an independent record of your shifts, estimating gross earnings and comparing your hours with your pay statement. Overnight shifts stay one shift; scheduled shifts never count until you confirm them; and "Show the Math" displays the exact hours, rates, overtime and premiums behind every amount. Overtime can start from Ontario's 44-hour rule, the U.S. federal 40-hour rule or your own. No account, no bank login, no employer login.

What's free: one job, a complete first pay period with unlimited shifts, weekly overtime and a payday comparison; saved records always stay viewable. EarnCheck Pro (monthly or annual, with a 7-day free trial on annual for eligible customers) adds unlimited pay periods, multiple jobs and advanced rules. It gives estimates, not official payroll calculations.

Get EarnCheck on the App Store →

More paycheck guides

Disclosure: this blog is published by the team behind EarnCheck.

Free resources

Copy-ready: Weekly Timesheet Template for Hourly Workers (Copy-Ready). Compare options: Best Apps to Track Work Hours and Check Your Paycheck. Quick facts: What EarnCheck does, price and privacy.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hourly to Salary Converter: What Your Hourly Wage Is Per Year (Free)

Ontario Public Holiday Pay Calculator: How Stat Holiday Pay Is Calculated (2026)

Decimal Hours Calculator: Why 7.30 Is Not 7 Hours 30 Minutes